of KINGS & carnies Before I Tell You That …

WTF?

Cover Me

My wife doesn’t like cover bands. She’d rather hear an original, badly written song than hear a re-tread.

Me? I like a good cover band. I like to hear a song I didn’t like in its original version covered well (think Michael Jackson’s “Smooth Criminal” covered by Alien Ant Farm). And I like to hear a very good original song covered in a style I normally wouldn’t listen to (think Soundgarden’s “Black Hole Sun” covered by Steve & Edie).

Ever since the Wife-Beast and I happened upon a bad (she says “not-that-bad”) cover band last week I’ve been thinking about what songs I’d play if I were in a cover band. My thoughts have gotten no farther than the first song.

As far as I’m concerned that first song has to startle you, kick you in the teeth. These are the three songs I’ve come up with — and you have to do a kick-ass version, go loud or go home:

  1. Love Removal Machine” by The Cult. Too obscure? Try;
  2. You Shook Me All Night Long” by AC/DC. Or almost anything by AC/DC;
  3. “LA Woman” by The Doors.

You should end with a ballad. Something you can slow dance to with that last chance chick.

NEVER, EVER end with Semisonic’s “Closing Time.” EVER. If you do, you and your band-mates are humps.

Around here, the Jersey Shore, you have to end with Springsteen’s version of Tom Waits’s “Jersey Girl.” It makes every drunk girl in New Jersey feel special. You can put your arm around her and sway to it — you don’t even have to dance! And if you can walk out the door with your arm around her, there’s a good chance that you’ll at least get to second base. Even if you’re married to her.

Yes, I called bands that close with “Closing Time” humps.

If you liked that, maybe you will like this:


2 Comments

Whether or not you think of the Beatles as one of the greatest rock bands of all time (I would put them in that category), they became brilliant songwriters only after years of performing as a cover band in Germany. Looking back, the breadth of material they played is astounding, and there’s no doubt they were successful by following your formula: Little Richard kicking ass to start the set, Everly Brothers slow and crooning to close it out. I’m with you. I love a good cover band.

Posted by GK on 10 June 2008 @ 8pm

I cut my musical teeth on The Beatles and hold their music in the highest stead. I believe they transcend music genre - their songs didn’t just influence rock music, they’ve music.

As a cover band, I have no argument with you at all.

I’ve been thinking about the middle of my cover sets. I think you need a mix of songs with really good hooks (maybe even some of those songs that seem to be all chorus) mixed with songs that everyone knows.

My good friend, Unky Rich (who was a singer in a cover band), says that crowds respond well to pop songs covered outside your genre. His band, a pop rock cover band, did a disco medley that people went ape-shit for.

Posted by Jim on 11 June 2008 @ 10am

Leave a Comment

The Idiocy of Boyhood Nonsequitors for 2008-06-10